Mr. – Ready for the Lube!

So it was time to take the Kia in for an oil change. As I am past the initial 1st. year and it was a Saturday I thought I would take it over to the local Mr. Lube instead of booking an appointment at the Dealer in the next week or so. Now I have been taking cars to Mr. Lube for quite some time and have to say at this point that the service is always friendly and fast.

There was only one car ahead of me so it’s going to be a quick in and out. I was greeted as usual and asked what service I was looking for, just an oil change and filter. Part way through the service the Tech brought me the air filter, showed me that it was dirty and, since it was the original filter, I decided to have them change it. Same with the cabin filter! Happy with the service I paid the $175.00 and was on my way in less than twenty minutes.

So I get home and crack open a pop and say to myself “$175.00 that’s a little rich” so I grabbed the Invoice to see where the costs were. The two biggest items were the Air Filter $37.99 and Cabin filter at $69.95. On Monday morning I called the local Kia Dealer to get a cost for the Cabin Filter – $32.95. Armed with this it was back to Mr. Lube.

I met with the Tech who had installed the unit, told him that I thought there had been “a mistake” in the pricing and I assumed that he ran in the wrong SKU. I was told that this was not the fact. He explained that the “extra costs” were for installation. Now Mr. Lube has you sit in the car so I had watched him open my glove compartment, show me the filter and install the new one. This total process took about 45 seconds. I’ll be generous here and push it to a minute.

So assuming that Mr. Lube charges the same for an aftermarket filter as the Dealer charges for a Kia branded filter this means that I paid $37.00 for a minutes worth of “installation” or $2,200.00/hour.

I was told by the tech to go on-line and complete the satisfaction survey and when asked for comments express my concerns. This I did – no one ever got back to me.

So this is a U.S. vs. Canadian pricing blog so what would this cost me in the U.S.? Last week I went to N.J. to visit some friends. We went to the local Pep Boys and I purchased a spare Cabin Filter (Purolator) for $19.95. I asked how much it would cost to have it installed and was told there was no charge. Air Filter was $8.95. On Line price at  even better at $11.95 plus $5.50 Shipping $17.45.

Total savings in U.S $79.04

About 2sidesof49

This Blog is for all Canadian Cross-Border Shoppers wanting to maximize their returns on their U.S. shopping trips. Visit for tips and tricks and links to our partners websites, blogs and products. Also check out my book The Canadian Cross-Border Shopping Guide - guaranteed to save you money!
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Mr. – Ready for the Lube!

  1. flynnroad says:

    American car parts stores will install some items for free. Batteries too.
    But, I think if you went to a Valvoline or other instant oil change service you would find installation isn’t free. For a fair comparison you should check with Valvoline or Jiffy Lube on cabin filter change prices. Also, in the US, I have never been allowed to sit in the driver’s seat while the oil change was happening. I assumed it was for safety reason. But, perhaps it was also so you didn’t get a $37 training class on how to change your own cabin filter 🙂

  2. Mike says:

    So why don’t you make your own hamburger patty and cook it instead of going to mcdonalds. You could save yourself another 4 bucks!!! Lol

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s